Name: Tony's Pizza
Address: 2555 Huntington Dr, San Marino, California, 91108, US
Telephone: +1 626-793-4114
Price range: $1-10

Welcome to Tony's Pizza

Signature Dining Experience

Tony's Pizza stands as a beloved local gem located at 2555 Huntington Dr, San Marino, CA. This pizza restaurant has cultivated a thriving community around its famous New York-style pizza, welcoming patrons with the rich aroma of freshly baked pies. From students to families, the atmosphere buzzes with excitement, especially during peak hours.

The menu features an array of options, including mouthwatering meatball sandwiches and barbecue chicken pizzas, drawing in pizza enthusiasts from far and wide. Students love the special deals offered that make indulging in their favorite slices both fun and affordable. Whether dining in or grabbing a slice to-go, Tony's Pizza delivers fresh, satisfying experiences for everyone.

Location & Contact

Address

2555 Huntington Dr, San Marino, CA 91108, United States

Phone

+1 626-793-4114

Social Media

About

Established as a community staple, Tony's Pizza has won the hearts of San Marino locals and visitors alike. Every slice tells a story, reflecting a commitment to quality and flavor that has stood the test of time. Located in the heart of San Marino, this pizza haven embraces customer feedback and continuously adapts to meet the community's expectations.

The culinary team creates pizzas that are not just meals but experiences. Customers rave about iconic menu items, particularly the NY-style pizza, which showcases Tony’s deep respect for traditional methods infused with a personal flair.

The meatball sandwich, often hailed as a must-try, resonates with those craving hearty comfort food. Rates for pizza slices average around $1.50, making it an accessible and delicious option for anyone on a budget.

Tony's places heavy emphasis on community involvement, frequently participating in local events and school programs. This dedication to creating a welcoming environment solidifies its reputation as more than just a restaurant; it's a gathering spot for friends and families. With Fridays being the busiest days, locals often plan their visits around these peak hours, eager to indulge in the classic and innovative flavors offered. Tony’s Pizza isn't just a dining locale; it's where memories are made, and flavors are celebrated.

Work Hours

Sunday1-8 PM
Monday11 AM-8 PM
Tuesday11 AM-8 PM
Wednesday11 AM-8 PM
Thursday11 AM-8 PM
Friday11 AM-8 PM
Saturday11 AM-8 PM

Tony's Pizza separates itself from the competition with its diverse offerings, particularly its thin crust and Sicilian-style pizza. The restaurant prioritizes quality, serving up slices made from the freshest ingredients, ensuring that every bite bursts with flavor.

Another key feature is the welcoming vibe; whether you opt for a cozy indoor experience or take advantage of the outdoor seating, the spot is perfect for a relaxed meal.

The popular Student Special reflects Tony's commitment to value, catering specifically to its young clientele. They're known for their efficient service during busy periods, allowing customers to enjoy their meals without long waits. The ambiance is lively, especially during peak hours, making it an ideal place to gather with friends.

The exterior of Tony's Pizza exudes a casual charm. Nestled along Huntington Drive, the restaurant features inviting signage that beckons pizza lovers from the street. The outdoor seating area is perfect for enjoying a slice on a sunny day, fostering a relaxed community feel.

Inside, the vibe is lively, with the sound of laughter and conversation accompanying the aroma of sizzling pies. It’s a space that encourages gathering and connection among friends and families, delivering not just a meal but a true community experience.

Customer Reviews

I've been coming to Tony's Pizza for as long as I can remember. Growing up, nothing beat the student special with a slushie--those are core childhood memories for me. I always thought the same Sicilian family would run Tony's forever, passing it down through the generations. So when I found out there were new owners, I'll admit I was nervous. But to my relief, it's still Tony's pizza! The taste, the atmosphere, the comfort--it all brought me back. That being said, I have to mention one small (but big to me) detail: the onions. My go-to has always been sausage and onion, and Tony's was special because of how they cut them--thin, long, stringy slices that caramelized perfectly in the oven. The new cut is different--chopped longer, thinner pieces--which just doesn't hit the same. It might sound silly, but for me, that little detail made their pizza stand out from anywhere else. One friendly suggestion for the new owners: please don't swap out the original ingredients for other brands. The magic of Tony's is in the flavor that's been consistent for decades. Don't change that! All in all, I'm so glad Tony's is still here and still delicious. Change is part of life, but the heart of Tony's pizza lives on.

Katie C.

The workers are nice and funny. They got pretty good pizza too with some thin - ish but wide pizza slices. Only came here once and I think it might be my favorite local pizza spot.

Brian M.

Excellent pizza, the Sicilian deep dish is absolutely incredible and a terrific value!! Wait for it. There is no viable online ordering system. Just call and pick it up, like in the old days.

E. B.

Tony's Pizza is not the same anymore, for all the best reasons! The pizza I remembered from high school was inedible cardboard. I have nostalgic memories of sitting in the red-and-green booths struggling to chew thru the stale crust on awkward first dates. The pizza now is so satisfying and a major improvement, with the same menu as before. I love the new crust texture. The pizza is not as greasy nor guilty as a NYC slice but would hold up well comparatively. I am sad to see the spate of negative reviews from people who seem attached more to the nostalgia of old Tony's and fail to see the major improvements the new owners have made to entire operation. I walk in and it's a breath of fresh air: extremely clean, gone are the days of the musty salad display and flour-covered floors. I visited recently to relive my high school days and left pleasantly impressed by delightful pizza.

Christine S.

Tony's Pizza supported my mom's art exhibit this afternoon. All of the guests were surprised with these thin crust pizzas, not just they were delicious but healthier than the thick crust. Thank you Lily for your support for local events.

L X.

After we moved to Alhambra, we needed a go-to pizza place for the family, and Tony's has become our favorite pizzeria. We have tried different toppings, and our favorites are BBQ chicken and pepperoni, so far. Staff is friendly and service is good.

Angeline H.

Tony's Pizza